digraph nodeset1723 { 8837 [label="analyses"]; 33313 [label="my concern is just this: I\nwant the freedom to be able to\nwrite off debts"]; 33314 [label="ND recognises this – there\nis this sort of sense amongst\na lot of young people, who\njust think, “I want that, so\nI’ll have that now. Thank\nyou.”"]; 33315 [label="if you want the moral hazard,\ninstead of kind of just going\non about the bankers, is there\nnot a danger that if we just\nsaid we’d write off debt,\nthat it actually isn’t very\nhelpful for our side, for\nordinary people, to actually\nhave that?"]; 33316 [label="There’s no discipline there"]; 33317 [label="In some ways you need that\ndiscipline, don’t you, to be\na saver, to think, “I\nwon’t get into debt”?"]; 33318 [label="If you want the economy to run\nsmoothly, you have to\nincentivise certain types of\nbehaviour."]; 33319 [label="CF : I understand that"]; 33320 [label="Weak Asserting"]; 33321 [label="CF : I suppose my concern is\njust this: I want the freedom\nto be able to write off debts"]; 33322 [label="Strong Asserting"]; 33323 [label="CF : ND recognises this –\nthere is this sort of sense\namongst a lot of young people,\nwho just think, “I want\nthat, so I’ll have that now.\nThank you.”"]; 33324 [label="Rhetorical Questioning"]; 33325 [label="CF : if you want the moral\nhazard, instead of kind of\njust going on about the\nbankers, is there not a danger\nthat if we just said we’d\nwrite off debt, that it\nactually isn’t very helpful\nfor our side, for ordinary\npeople, to actually have that?"]; 33326 [label="Asserting"]; 33327 [label="CF : There’s no discipline\nthere"]; 33328 [label="Asserting"]; 33329 [label="CF : In some ways you need\nthat discipline, don’t you,\nto be a saver, to think, “I\nwon’t get into debt”?"]; 33330 [label="TA"]; 33331 [label="TA"]; 33332 [label="Opposed Commitment"]; 33333 [label="Disagreeing"]; 33334 [label="TA"]; 33335 [label="TA"]; 33336 [label="Modus Ponens"]; 33337 [label="Arguing"]; 33338 [label="ND : In some ways I agree with\nyou"]; 33339 [label="Asserting"]; 33340 [label="ND : If you want the economy\nto run smoothly, you have to\nincentivise certain types of\nbehaviour."]; 33341 [label="in South Korea, in terms of\nhow South Korean grew, it did\nincentivise saving, at certain\ntimes, by certain economic\npolicies"]; 33342 [label="people don’t realise, or\nonly half realise, is the fact\nthat we have actually written\noff massive amounts of debt"]; 33343 [label="But it certainly isn’t the\ndebts of the people who most\nneed it in society"]; 33344 [label="Asserting"]; 33345 [label="ND : So, for example in South\nKorea, in terms of how South\nKorean grew, it did\nincentivise saving, at certain\ntimes, by certain economic\npolicies"]; 33346 [label="Weak Asserting"]; 33347 [label="ND : On the other hand, I\nthink what people don’t\nrealise, or only half realise,\nis the fact that we have\nactually written off massive\namounts of debt"]; 33348 [label="Asserting"]; 33349 [label="ND : But it certainly isn’t\nthe debts of the people who\nmost need it in society"]; 33350 [label="TA"]; 33351 [label="Agreeing"]; 33352 [label="TA"]; 33353 [label="Established Rule"]; 33354 [label="Arguing"]; 33355 [label="TA"]; 33356 [label="Example"]; 33357 [label="Arguing"]; 33358 [label="Sign From Other Events"]; 33359 [label="TA"]; 33360 [label="Disagreeing"]; 33361 [label="we shouldn’t encourage it\nfor ourselves either"]; 33362 [label="there’s a danger when you\nkind of say, “The poor are\nthe ones who suffer. The rich\nare the bad guys.”"]; 33363 [label="It is the case that some of\nthe greatest examples of\nsocial progress over the years\nhave come from well-off rich\npeople, banks and so on,\ninvesting productively"]; 33364 [label="Isn’t the problem that the\nonly thing the banks have done\nis kind of consumer credit?"]; 33365 [label="What they should have been\ndoing, what they could be\ndoing, and what they haven’t\ngot the nerve to do, is not\nloaning enough"]; 33366 [label="They should actually be taking\nmore risk and giving more\nmoney out"]; 33367 [label="ND : For productive\ninvestments. I agree with you."]; 33368 [label="Asserting"]; 33369 [label="CF : Yes, but what I\'m saying\nis we shouldn’t encourage it\nfor ourselves either"]; 33370 [label="CF : That’s my point."]; 33371 [label="Weak Asserting"]; 33372 [label="CF : And then finally, if I\ncould just ask you, there’s\na danger I think when you kind\nof say, “The poor are the\nones who suffer. The rich are\nthe bad guys.”"]; 33373 [label="Asserting"]; 33374 [label="CF : It is the case that some\nof the greatest examples of\nsocial progress over the years\nhave come from well-off rich\npeople, banks and so on,\ninvesting productively"]; 33375 [label="Rhetorical Questioning"]; 33376 [label="CF : Isn’t the problem that\nthe only thing the banks have\ndone is kind of consumer\ncredit?"]; 33377 [label="Asserting"]; 33378 [label="CF : What they should have\nbeen doing, what they could be\ndoing, and what they haven’t\ngot the nerve to do, is not\nloaning enough"]; 33379 [label="Asserting"]; 33380 [label="CF : They should actually be\ntaking more risk and giving\nmore money out"]; 33381 [label="TA"]; 33382 [label="TA"]; 33383 [label="TA"]; 33384 [label="TA"]; 33385 [label="Example"]; 33386 [label="Arguing"]; 33387 [label="Popular Opinion"]; 33388 [label="TA"]; 33389 [label="TA"]; 33390 [label="Arguing"]; 33391 [label="TA"]; 33392 [label="Practical Reasoning"]; 33393 [label="Arguing"]; 33394 [label="TA"]; 33395 [label="Agreeing"]; 33320 -> 33313; 8837 -> 33320; 33321 -> 33320; 33322 -> 33314; 8837 -> 33322; 33323 -> 33322; 33324 -> 33315; 8837 -> 33324; 33325 -> 33324; 33326 -> 33316; 8837 -> 33326; 33327 -> 33326; 33328 -> 33317; 8837 -> 33328; 33329 -> 33328; 33330 -> 33321; 8837 -> 33330; 33319 -> 33330; 33331 -> 33323; 33331 -> 33333; 8837 -> 33331; 33321 -> 33331; 33332 -> 33313; 8837 -> 33332; 33314 -> 33332; 33333 -> 33332; 8837 -> 33333; 33334 -> 33325; 8837 -> 33334; 33323 -> 33334; 33335 -> 33327; 33335 -> 33329; 33335 -> 33337; 8837 -> 33335; 33325 -> 33335; 33336 -> 33315; 8837 -> 33336; 33316 -> 33336; 33317 -> 33336; 33337 -> 33336; 8837 -> 33337; 33339 -> 33318; 8837 -> 33339; 33340 -> 33339; 33344 -> 33341; 8837 -> 33344; 33345 -> 33344; 33346 -> 33342; 8837 -> 33346; 33347 -> 33346; 33348 -> 33343; 8837 -> 33348; 33349 -> 33348; 33350 -> 33338; 33350 -> 33351; 8837 -> 33350; 33329 -> 33350; 33351 -> 33317; 8837 -> 33351; 33352 -> 33340; 33352 -> 33354; 8837 -> 33352; 33338 -> 33352; 33353 -> 33317; 8837 -> 33353; 33318 -> 33353; 33354 -> 33353; 8837 -> 33354; 33355 -> 33345; 33355 -> 33357; 8837 -> 33355; 33340 -> 33355; 33356 -> 33318; 8837 -> 33356; 33341 -> 33356; 33357 -> 33356; 8837 -> 33357; 33358 -> 33317; 8837 -> 33358; 33342 -> 33358; 33343 -> 33358; 33360 -> 33358; 33359 -> 33347; 33359 -> 33349; 33359 -> 33360; 8837 -> 33359; 33329 -> 33359; 8837 -> 33360; 33368 -> 33361; 8837 -> 33368; 33369 -> 33368; 33371 -> 33362; 8837 -> 33371; 33372 -> 33371; 33373 -> 33363; 8837 -> 33373; 33374 -> 33373; 33375 -> 33364; 8837 -> 33375; 33376 -> 33375; 33377 -> 33365; 8837 -> 33377; 33378 -> 33377; 33379 -> 33366; 8837 -> 33379; 33380 -> 33379; 33381 -> 33369; 8837 -> 33381; 33349 -> 33381; 33382 -> 33370; 8837 -> 33382; 33369 -> 33382; 33383 -> 33372; 8837 -> 33383; 33370 -> 33383; 33384 -> 33374; 33384 -> 33386; 8837 -> 33384; 33372 -> 33384; 33385 -> 33362; 8837 -> 33385; 33363 -> 33385; 33386 -> 33385; 8837 -> 33386; 33387 -> 33364; 8837 -> 33387; 33365 -> 33387; 33390 -> 33387; 33388 -> 33378; 33388 -> 33390; 8837 -> 33388; 33376 -> 33388; 33389 -> 33376; 8837 -> 33389; 33374 -> 33389; 8837 -> 33390; 33391 -> 33380; 33391 -> 33393; 8837 -> 33391; 33376 -> 33391; 33392 -> 33366; 8837 -> 33392; 33364 -> 33392; 33393 -> 33392; 8837 -> 33393; 33394 -> 33367; 33394 -> 33395; 8837 -> 33394; 33380 -> 33394; 33395 -> 33366; 8837 -> 33395;}